The Overtake

In their attempt to oust the state-appointed superintendent, Camden’s officials may actually achieve the coup they want without local control of its schools being returned.

A Camden school building reflects the ongoing debate over public education, school enrollment and local control in the city. Credit: Smallbones

Fela Aníkúlápó Kuti, the Nigerian artist and musical genius who invented the genre known as Afrobeat, was known for half-hour songs with driving rhythms that accompanied sharp commentary against the oppressive forces of his country’s corrupt government. One of my many favorites in his catalog was a song whose title I didn’t quite understand: “Overtake Don Overtake Overtake” (O.D.O.O.). 

The song speaks of poverty, military overpolicing, and the illusions of democracy—experiences had in many communities populated by Black and brown people. From Lagos to American cities like Camden, the promise of school education gives families hope—hope that it may help defend against these things and open pathways to a brighter, more equitable future for their children and generations to come. 

A Closer Look at One Camden’s Enrollment Model

Traditionally, students are enrolled each year in the public school assigned to them within their local school district. If a parent chooses a different route, such as enrolling their child(ren) in a charter or private school, they can do so while notifying their local district so their children can be unenrolled. 

In other words, school districts retain responsibility for enrolling students within their jurisdiction unless a parent chooses otherwise. However, if a school district chooses to participate in a universal enrollment system with other schools outside its district, it relinquishes that control. That’s what the Camden City School District (CCSD) did when it joined the One Camden enrollment program. 

One Camden is a universal enrollment program that gives Camden parents a streamlined process for selecting a school for their child(ren) from two options: a CCSD school or a Renaissance charter school. Traditional charter schools opted to retain autonomy over their enrollment procedures. One could argue that the system’s architects created it this way to encourage “competition” between schools; in a capitalist society, competition is supposed to benefit the consumer. 

The keyword is supposed. But this is no competition. 

Competition would mean more choices for parents (outside of Camden City). Instead, this system is designed to increase attendance at Renaissance School in Camden. 

A System Designed to Divert Students from CCSD

Although the Urban Hope Act mandates that Renaissance Schools automatically enroll students within a certain radius, One Camden allows any student in the city to attend the school of their choice. 

The law has shifted Camden’s enrollment numbers from CCSD to charter schools. But One Camden has accelerated that shift even further. According to CCSD data, only 31% of Camden City public school students attend CCSD schools, while 40% attend Renaissance Schools and 20% attend traditional charters. 

Champions of universal school enrollment argue that CCSD helped create and implement it. But the truth is that a state-appointed superintendent, representing the state of New Jersey and not community members, decided the extent to which residents were allowed to be involved. And when public school funding is already scarce, compared to Renaissance schools with marketing budgets, the playing field is anything but level when it comes to recruiting students. 

Such a system, therefore, sets CCSD up for reduced enrollment, to the point of dissolution, as I’ve argued already. Camden’s current state-appointed superintendent, Alfonso Llano, must have noticed the disadvantage as well and, in response, made the bold decision to withdraw CCSD from One Camden’s universal enrollment apparatus, much to the chagrin of municipal and school district officials. One Camden’s Executive Director Tameeka Mason called it a “misinformed policy decision.”

In response, those officials have asked Governor Sherrill to remove Llano from his post in a letter signed by the mayor and numerous officials.

This happened with Katrina McCombs, the state-appointed superintendent Llano replaced. In 2024, a cohort of Camden officials, Mayor Victor Carstarphen, State Sen. Nilsa Cruz-Perez, Assemblyman William Spearman, Camden City Council President Angel Fuentes, and Camden Advisory Board President N’Namdee Nelson, collectively petitioned the education commissioner to remove McCombs because they “[believed] that a fresh direction is necessary to fully address the evolving needs of our students and educators.”

This time, a host of stakeholders from the advisory board (not including the board president), municipal and state government—including Carstarphen, Cruz-Perez, Spearman, and Fuentes—former Camden Mayor Dana Redd, and Camden Education Fund CEO Giana Campbell, signed their names to a letter—on municipal and CEF letterhead—calling for Llano’s removal as well as restoring CCSD to the universal enrollment system. 

The vast majority of the signees are members of the Camden County Democratic Party, so it’s highly plausible that party leaders are on board with this ask, if not outright captaining the ship, although their names are absent from this letter. 

Camden’s Neo-Colonial Future: A Battle for Political Control

The mentality underpinning the takeover of Black and brown communities is rooted in a white power structure that assumes control over their political institutions and resources under the pretense that it knows what’s best for people, namely Black and brown, who, in its view, lack the capacity to govern themselves. That, in short, is neo-colonialism, and the narrative that we see playing out in Camden.

That narrative began in the 1950s and 60s, when Black and brown folks moved into the city in larger numbers. My grandparents arrived in Camden from Attapulgus, GA, during the Great Migration of the 1960s. They witnessed Camden transform from an industrial leader to a post-industrial relic, where white flight drove their businesses to the neighboring suburbs. 

Left behind were Black and brown residents who struggled to initiate or maintain economic power for themselves because of racism. 

The systemic racism that denied Black and brown residents equitable access to employment, fair wages, and entrepreneurial opportunities also undermined their ability to exercise political power once it was obtained. This history is central to understanding why twenty years of Black and brown leadership at City Hall became a journey down the road to perdition, ultimately culminating in twenty-five years of state intervention shaped by the very power structure that abandoned Camden as  Black and brown residents moved into the city. 

Llano seems to be trying to travel down his own road. But the governor will ultimately determine where Camden ends up. 

It remains unclear what the governor will do. Her administration is expected to hear Camden officials’ concerns, but it is plausible—and likely—that Llano made this decision with the knowledge of either the governor or the state education commissioner. After all, the superintendent serves as the governor’s representative in Camden. 

But in the words of former governor Phil Murphy: “We’re from Jersey…” and in Jersey, it’s all about the politics. If Gov. Sherrill chooses to stand behind Llano, she could find herself in the crosshairs of George Norcross, who maintains considerable power and influence over Camden’s political establishment. When Governor, Murphy initially appeared willing to challenge Norcross, but whatever tensions existed between the two were eventually quelled, and the political order returned to business as usual. Sherrill may not have the political capital or support to take on Norcross the same way. Nevertheless, Llano may have put her in the middle of a fight she didn’t ask for. 

Whatever she decides will have a seismic impact on Camden schools and Camden City going forward. Keep Llano in power, and a fight for control will be underway. But I fear that the governor will cave to this challenge, further cementing Camden’s neo-colonial status, affirming the right of the few to rule the rights of the many. 

If the state relinquishes its authority at the behest of the officials from whom it once stripped that authority, then who was the takeover ever meant to serve? Was the 2013 rhetoric about acting in the best interests of Camden’s students genuine, or was the takeover ultimately about consolidating power? 

Removing Llano from his position could be catastrophic because of the message it would send. That message is that the power to govern Camden now belongs in the hands of a political machine versus the state; a machine that dictates elections to determine the fate of Black and brown people assumed to be incapable of governing themselves. If the County Democrats get their way, what follows is not a return to local control, but a takeover of the takeover.

That’s what Fela’s song means.

Don overtake translates to the overtaking has been overtaken by another overtaking. The overtake of state intervention is the kind of coup Fela warns about. It’s the kind that Camden’s residents may never recover from. It’s the kind where nothing in Camden will be out of reach for the County Machine. The first overtake changed municipal government. The second changed law enforcement. But this one, over Camden’s schools, sets the stage for the death of a district and a death to democracy. 

This fear isn’t a revelation so much as a clearer vision of what can come from a power structure that offers people the illusion of choice in who leads. But binary politics only offers two sides of the same coin; no matter which side sits up, the coin spends the same. 

Don overtake.