Q&A: Why Desegregating Isn’t Enough

Julie O’Connor, Urban education writer (NJ Spotlight)

New Jersey’s Supreme Court is expected to consider a case that could force massive efforts to diversify schools in this state, one of the nation’s worst when it comes to segregation. But some scholars say integrating classrooms won’t change much on its own.

What really matters in escaping poverty is how many wealthier friends you have, which is not automatically linked to the racial mix of a school.

A team of researchers from Harvard, Stanford, and New York University analyzed 21 billion Facebook friendships alongside tax records up through 2021 to reveal a striking trend: Poor kids who befriend wealthier peers grow up to earn far more money.

In fact, these friendships beat out factors like better school funding, family structure or neighborhood wealth as the top driver of climbing out of poverty, likely because of real-world perks like job leads, insider advice and big ambitions.

Stanford economist Matthew Jackson, a co-author on the study, spoke to NJ Spotlight about why desegregating schools isn’t enough, and what it really takes to make this effort work. Below is a lightly edited transcript.

Julie O’Connor, NJ Spotlight News: You’ve found that mixing kids of different races is no magic bullet. First, what does the research say? Does integration lift the performance of minority kids, or is it more complicated?

Matthew Jackson: Part of it is, what does one mean by integration? Building a school that’s balanced on ethnicity or income lines doesn’t necessarily mean that the kids inside the school interact.

When you look at the research, you do see that large schools with diverse sets of students sometimes can be the most fractured in terms of the friendship patterns. Integration means more than just building schools that have populations of kids together. You actually have to foster meaningful interaction between those kids that results in real friendships, and that’s a lot more than just putting students on the same campus.

JO: You emphasize the importance of mixed neighborhoods, not just schools. But a school district can’t change the racial mix-up of its neighborhood, can it?

MJ: No. So, it is tricky. But nonetheless, I think there are a lot of areas where it’s possible to build school districts that can be reasonably integrated. One thing we find in our research is that it is not just racial integration, but that an important connection is between children whose parents have relatively lower income, to other students whose parents have slightly higher or higher income.

These cross-class connections make a big difference in a kids’ future trajectory – whether they go to college, what their future earnings are – who they’re connected to, in terms of their friends’ parents.

And whether friendships exist between people of different income levels varies a lot by geography. When you look across the country – across counties, across zip codes within high schools, different places — there’s enormous variation across the U.S. in how economically-connected different communities are. And those cross-economic class connections seem to be the ones that really make a difference in predicting a kid’s future trajectory.

A lot of areas do have relatively higher income families and relatively lower ones. Making sure they have a possibility of interacting and that children, in particular, can form those friendships – that seems to be essential.

JO: You found that kids need to form friendships across racial lines before integration starts to produce good results?

MJ: Yes. It’s not just ethnicity. The kids with poorer families tend to do better in areas where they have potential for friendships with people who are better off economically, and they do worse if they don’t have those connections. Racial segregation plays into that because income is correlated with race, but the importance of friendships that connect people across income levels is there regardless of whether you have racial segregation.

For instance, in one of our studies, we find that when you look just at a kid from a lower income, and what that kid’s friends’ family incomes are, that’s predictive of the future, regardless of whether you are looking at areas above 90% white, or areas that are more racially diverse.

JO: So, the economic boost of having wealthier friends works the same way for kids in every type of demographic setting?

MJ: Right.

JO: Tell us about cases where this has worked. What steps did the school take to promote it?

MJ: One clue is that schools that are more successful in the data are smaller schools. They tend to be ones that end up doing better at integrating students’ friendships across both racial and economic lines.

We have studied what we call “friending bias,” which is the tendency of people to form friendships primarily with others who share their own income status, even when they are exposed to people whose income differs from their own. That varies widely across schools in the U.S.

Larger schools tend to have more friending bias, as do schools that have more tracking—where, essentially, people who have higher income, more educated parents, or tutors and so forth might be tracked into honors programs. And people who are first-generation end up tracked into other programs. That builds, even within the same school, separate populations.

Somehow, places that tend to integrate across those lines are ones offering those opportunities, but it requires not only having the exposure, but also then eliminating that friending bias. That second part is harder to do.

It does mean that you need sustained interaction on a micro-level, and general proximity of two populations is not enough to foster those cross-group friendships.

JO: Are clubs and sports more effective than sitting in the same classroom for making these friendships, or not?

MJ: Yes. Where the friending bias seems to be lower are in extracurricular places or religious institutions, places where people are meeting in smaller groups and teams and have the opportunity to interact across economic lines.

It depends on the extracurricular, sport or venue to some extent. For instance, some sports are very heavily segregated by income and take a lot of investment. We find universities, for instance, with strong sorority and fraternity systems tend to have higher friending bias; likely because joining those groups can be expensive and so can segregate people across economic lines. So having organizations that have the potential to bring people together doesn’t necessarily work unless those groups themselves are going to be ones that tend to integrate people across economic divides.

JO: What lessons do you see here for policymakers and educators?

MJ: The main message that we’ve seen, now pretty clearly, in the data seems to be that friendships for children matter a lot, and having those be economically diverse and connecting people across economic class lines is very important. Moreover, the earlier it happens, it seems, the better off children are in general.

Having an organization where you’re just putting people in proximity isn’t the same as actually having people work together. For example, for a large high school that has many tracked courses, one wants to ensure that there are at least some classes in which students from completely different backgrounds are put together to work in small teams.

Or, one can develop a program where students from AP or honors courses are put together with students from a first-generation background to work on some collaborative project.

Those are the sorts of changes – beyond ensuring that a school is integrated to begin with – that foster meaningful interactions that can potentially lead to transformative friendships. This comes on top of programs that are designed to help desegregate populations at a more macro-level. That desegregation is just the first step, which is of course necessary, but not enough to ensure that cross-group friendships form.

There’s a lot of reasons to believe that these should matter. That’s how people get aspirations: What are your norms, what are you doing after school, what are other kids doing? Kids tend to emulate each other, and there’s a lot of indirect information, preferences, aspirations and norms that are built through these friendships. So, an organization that just puts people in proximity isn’t the same as one that actually puts people together in a meaningful way.

This story was originally published by NJ Spotlight News through the NJ News Wire.