Giants Ride Preseason Momentum Into 2025, But Can They Handle What’s Ahead?

New York, New York-The New York Giants closed their 2025 preseason with a flawless 3-0 record, outscoring Buffalo, the Jets, and New England by a combined 107–47. While this is a promising start, it is not necessarily an indicator of regular-season success. The actual test will come in the upcoming games, starting with next week’s opener in Washington.

Preseason Recap

New York opened with a 34–25 road win over the Bills, featuring impressive QB work from both Russell Wilson and rookie Jaxson Dart. Against the Jets, Dart delivered two touchdown passes—closing the night on a 13-completion streak—while Wilson hit an 80-yard completion on his first throw, showcasing the team’s offensive prowess. 

The finale was a 42–10 dismantling of the Patriots. With starters watching, Dart picked up right where he’d left off: tossing another TD, finishing 6-for-12 for 81 yards, including a 50-yard connection with Gunner Olszewski, before exiting with a brief concussion scare. Tommy DeVito subbed in and threw three additional touchdowns. 

Dart’s Strong Debut Season

The first-round rookie (No. 25 overall out of Ole Miss) impressed throughout the preseason, completing 32 of 47 passes for 372 yards, three touchdowns, and zero interceptions. He added 52 rushing yards and scored once on the ground. 

In his debut against the Jets, several throws displayed remarkable poise—enough that veteran coach Brian Daboll and QB coach Shea Tierney openly praised his week-to-week development. 

Still, familiar voices urge caution. Giants’ legend Eli Manning offered public words of mentorship, reminding Dart to stay grounded amid the New York spotlight. And after a harsh critique of Dart by ex-QB Ryan Fitzpatrick backfired—thanks to Dart’s resilient bounce-back—it became clear the rookie is already earning respect, inspiring hope for his future in the team. 

Veteran Balance and Locker Room Tone

On offense, 10-time Pro Bowler Russell Wilson has anchored the room with leadership. Teammate Wan’Dale Robinson cited the QB room’s refreshed focus as a key source of optimism. Brian Daboll, for now, calls Dart QB3 behind Wilson and Jameis Winston, though Dart’s strong play is pushing him up the depth chart. 

Rookies Making an Impact

New faces turned heads beyond the QB position. First-round defensive end Abdul Carter played sparingly but stood out with every snap. Third-round pick Darius Alexander, from Toledo, also flashed skill in the trenches. And RB Cam Skattebo, who missed much of camp with a hamstring issue, returned to contribute in the preseason finale. 

The Schedule Doesn’t Let Up

There’s no easy ride ahead. New York opens the regular season in Washington on Sunday, September 7, then travels to Dallas before returning home for a prime-time matchup with the defending champion Kansas City Chiefs. 

Analysts warn it’s one of the toughest paths in the NFL due to the high number of games against 2024 playoff teams, with six of these games scheduled within the first eight weeks. This early stretch will be crucial in determining the Giants’ season trajectory. 

What Will Define This Season

Three factors stand out:

1. Quarterback play – Dart’s growth must continue, or Wilson must quickly regain his 2023 form.
2. Defensive and rushing core health – Rookies like Carter and Alexander need to stick around and perform.
3. Early resilience – With such a brutal schedule, the Giants can’t afford a slow start.

Final Thoughts

There’s reason for cautious optimism. A dominant preseason, breakout rookie moments, key contributions across offense and defense… the foundation may finally be in place. But August success doesn’t translate into wins come September. The real test begins on Sunday with Washington standing in the way of a season that might surprise.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR:

Darryl Jacobs is a nationally recognized sports journalist and basketball commentator/analyst, affiliated with esteemed networks such as ESPN, CBS, and NBA Television Sports Networks. As a seasoned sports executive with over 20 years of experience in higher education, corporate, professional sports leadership, and nonprofit management, Jacobs possesses a unique blend of expertise.

A recipient of an Honorary Doctorate in Humane Letters, Dr. Jacobs has collaborated extensively with professional athletes and has held leadership roles on several national boards focused on education, sports, and community development.